
This Day in History — The Holland Tunnel Opens Beneath the Hudson
On this day in 1927
At 12:01 a.m. on November 13, 1927, the Holland Tunnel opened, and 84 fans let cars drive under the Hudson without choking on their own exhaust.
The Off-Key Bard stands near the Hudson River on a chilly November night in 1927. Behind him, the lit streets of Manhattan climb toward a skyline of skyscrapers and factories. Across the water lies Jersey City. For generations, travelers have crossed these waters aboard ferries. But beneath the river there is now a new route: two tunnels lined with cast iron, concrete and millions of white tiles, where electric fans keep a constant current of fresh air moving. A few minutes after midnight, the first automobiles will drive in.
"The remarkable achievement is not simply that engineers have built a road underwater. It is that they have made the air inside safe enough for thousands of gasoline-powered vehicles to use it."
At 12:01 a.m. on Sunday, November 13, 1927, the Holland Tunnel opened to vehicles, linking Jersey City, New Jersey, with Lower Manhattan beneath the Hudson River. The American Society of Mechanical Engineers calls it "the world's first long underwater tunnel designed for motor vehicles," and says its ventilation system "has been the model for all succeeding vehicular tunnels." It cost about $48 million and took the better part of seven years to build.
The River in the Way
By the 1920s the ferry lines were jammed with cars and trucks. A bridge was impractical, according to American Heritage, which says a 1906 study had judged one so, and the river carried too much shipping for a low one. A tunnel would have to go beneath the riverbed, and it would have to be breathable.
That was the hard part. Gasoline engines produce carbon monoxide, a colorless, odorless gas that interferes with the blood's ability to carry oxygen. In the open it disperses. In a long tube it builds up, and stalled traffic makes it worse. American Heritage says Clifford Holland calculated that natural airflow from the ends would take a 75 mph wind, so he designed a mechanical system.
The Engineers
The project was originally called the Hudson River Vehicular Tunnel. Clifford Milburn Holland, born March 13, 1883, became its first chief engineer in 1919. After graduating from Harvard in 1906, he had worked on several New York subway tunnels. The official groundbreaking took place on October 12, 1920, while major shield-tunneling operations began in 1922. These dates describe different stages of the same construction project, rather than conflicting accounts of its beginning.
The strain was heavy. Holland suffered a nervous breakdown in October 1924 and went to a sanatorium in Battle Creek, Michigan, where he died of a heart attack at 41. The plaque dates his death October 27, 1924, while TunnelTalk gives October 28. Either way, it came about a day before the two halves of the tunnel were scheduled to meet. The Hagerty article says the link between his stress and his death is "likely" and not proven, and that is how it should be read. The project was renamed in his memory.
Milton H. Freeman took over, and he died of pneumonia on March 24, 1925. Ole Singstad, the Norwegian-born engineer who had worked under Holland since 1915, directed the rest of the work, and the plaque lists him as chief engineer from 1925 to 1929.
Digging Under the River
TunnelTalk says two shields, each 16 feet long and weighing 400 tons, excavated the twin tubes, with a forward thrust of 6,000 tons. A good day advanced a shield about 40 feet. The tubes were cast-iron lined, and the work was done by the pneumatic method, with air pressure inside the working area held high enough to keep water and silt out. American Heritage describes workers entering through air locks. It reports that 13 men died during the seven years of construction. The plaque credits only the deaths of Holland and Freeman, so the worker toll is a single-source figure.
Interior finishing was extensive. TunnelTalk counts about 3.1 million ceiling tiles and 2.9 million wall tiles. The finished project cost $48.4 million against an engineer's estimate of $28.7 million, according to TunnelTalk.
Singstad's Air
Ole Singstad's transverse ventilation system was the breakthrough that made the tunnel practical. Instead of relying on a strong current of air flowing from one entrance to the other, the design supplied fresh air along the tunnel's length. Fans drew outside air into ducts beneath the roadway, where it entered the traffic space through regularly spaced openings near the curbs. Exhaust fans pulled polluted air through openings in the ceiling and into separate overhead ducts, carrying it to ventilation buildings for discharge outdoors. This arrangement distributed fresh air throughout the tunnel rather than allowing exhaust fumes to accumulate progressively along the route. The design followed extensive engineering and physiological research, including experiments conducted with the U.S. Bureau of Mines.
Four ventilation buildings, two on each side of the Hudson, housed 84 fans: 42 supplying fresh air and 42 extracting exhaust. Together they provided approximately 6,000 horsepower of ventilation capacity. According to the American Society of Mechanical Engineers, the system could replace the tunnel's air approximately every 90 seconds when operating at full capacity. Carbon monoxide monitoring helped operators adjust ventilation to changing traffic conditions. The system established an engineering model for later long vehicular tunnels, demonstrating that mechanical ventilation could make an enclosed underwater roadway safe for sustained automobile traffic.
Opening Day
The official ceremonies took place on Saturday, November 12, 1927, the afternoon before vehicles could enter. At approximately 4:55 p.m., President Calvin Coolidge, aboard the presidential yacht Mayflower on the Potomac River, operated a ceremonial telegraph key previously used by President Woodrow Wilson during the opening of the Panama Canal. The signal traveled to the Holland Tunnel entrances, where bells announced the occasion and enormous American flags were to be drawn aside. Governors Al Smith of New York and A. Harry Moore of New Jersey participated in the ceremonies, alongside other officials and members of the tunnel commissions.
The tunnel was opened to pedestrians for a public inspection period from approximately 5 to 7 p.m. on November 12. Thousands of people walked beneath the Hudson before motor vehicles were admitted. Historical accounts differ on the crowd's precise size, but the event offered the public an unusual opportunity to experience the new crossing on foot. At 12:01 a.m. on Sunday, November 13, the Holland Tunnel opened to automobile traffic, beginning a new era of road transportation between Manhattan and Jersey City.
The first cars rolled at 12:01 a.m. The toll was 50 cents per car, according to the Port Authority and NJBMagazine.
The response was immediate. According to historian Robert W. Jackson's research, 52,285 vehicles passed through the Holland Tunnel during its first 24 hours of operation. The New York Times reported the same figure in its November 14, 1927 edition. Traffic was heavy almost from the beginning, demonstrating both the demand for a direct road crossing beneath the Hudson and the importance of a ventilation system capable of handling large numbers of automobiles.
The tunnel's key test was whether it would stay breathable under that load. According to Wikipedia's article on Singstad, carbon monoxide in the Holland Tunnel averaged 0.69 parts per 10,000 parts of air, well below the 4-per-10,000 maximum considered permissible. American Heritage notes that volunteer studies had shown that as little as 4 parts per 10,000 could be harmful.
Records and Claims
Words like "first" need care. ASME's designation and the Port Authority describe it as the first long underwater tunnel built for motor vehicles with a ventilation system designed for automobile exhaust. Wikipedia's article on Clifford Holland and Hagerty call it the first vehicular tunnel of its kind in the United States and the fifth in the world. The qualifier that matters is "long underwater," because the claim does not cover every road tunnel. What the sources agree on is narrower and safe: it was the first permanent vehicular crossing under the Hudson.
After the Opening
The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey took over operation in April 1930, according to Rockland Daily. The tunnel was honored in 1984 as a National Historic Civil and Mechanical Engineering Landmark, and the Interior Department designated it a National Historic Landmark in 1993, according to the Port Authority. The ASME landmark page lists the ventilation system separately, as landmark number 93.
In 2012 the tunnel faced a different test. The Holland Tunnel was closed before Hurricane Sandy, since its tubes are prone to flooding, and it reopened at 5 a.m. on Wednesday, November 7, 2012, after about a week, according to DNAinfo. An amNewYork report says the storm surge damaged 22 sites within the tunnel, with water entering through the New Jersey portals and the exhaust air duct system, and that repairs were estimated at $255 million, with FEMA providing $229.6 million. TunnelTalk notes the flood water was mostly seawater from the surge, which can be very damaging to electrical systems.
Beneath the Hudson, workers pressed,
Through mud and stone beneath its crest.
With roaring fans and lamps aglow,
The city's traffic flowed below.
The Holland Tunnel is remembered as a feat of digging, but most of what made it work is invisible to someone driving through. Few motorists see the ventilation buildings or think about the ducts and fans that keep the air breathable. The engineering that makes a structure usable can matter as much as the engineering that keeps it standing. A tunnel has to hold back the river, and it also has to keep the people inside it alive.
The project also shows how much of a landmark depends on people who are not remembered at the portal. Holland designed the project and did not live to see it open. Freeman took it up and died within months, and Singstad finished it and refined the ventilation that became a model for later road tunnels. Thousands of workers did the dangerous labor of digging beneath a major river. Nearly a century later, the crossing is still in use.
Sources
- Bridges and Tunnel History — Port Authority of New York and New Jersey
- Holland Tunnel Ventilation System — American Society of Mechanical Engineers
- The History of a Unique Engineering Achievement — American Society of Mechanical Engineers, illustrated technical booklet
- Holland Tunnel Construction Photographs and Reports — New-York Historical Society Collection, NYU Special Collections
- The Holland Tunnel Engineers Plaque — Historical Marker Database, transcription of original plaque
- One Work Complete — Highway under the Hudson — Robert W. Jackson, NYU Press
- Vehicle Tunnel Under Hudson River Opened — United Press, November 1927
- Holland Plaza Building Designation Report — New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission
- Tunnel to the Future — American Heritage, Jack Kelly